Since I have attended Najib’s open house, I would like to put LKS’ statement on this issue on my blog for you to read, just in case you miss it. 🙂
Fallacy to automatically equate Najib’s Hari Raya Open House crowd with support for his 1Malaysia slogan
The Prime Minister, Datuk Seri Najib Razak and the Cabinet Ministers’ Hari Raya Open House at Sri Perdana on the first day of the festivities on Sunday had a good crowd, but it is a fallacy to automatically equate Najib’s Hari Raya Open House crowd with support for his 1Malaysia slogan.
The mainstream media refer to a crowd of 50,000 to 60,000 for the Prime Minister’s Open House at Sri Perdana on Sunday.
If crowd numbers is a measure of public support for the incumbent Prime Minister’s policies and slogans, then how is one to interpret the crowd sizes of Hari Raya Open Houses of previous Prime Ministers, Tun Abdullah and Tun Mahathir?
A check with reports of past years will show the following crowd numbers cited in the mainstream media for Abdullah’s six Hari Raya Open Houses during his tenure as Prime Minister:
| 2003 | 70,000 | (NST 26.11.03) |
| 2004 | 200,000 | (NST/Malay Mail 16.11.04) |
| 2005 | 100,000 | (Malay Mail 5.11.05) |
| 2006 | 200,000 | (Berita Harian 26.10.06) |
| 2007 | 200,000 | (NST 15.10.07) |
| 2008 | 200,000 | (Harian Metro 3.10.08) |
With Najib’s first Hari Raya Open House crowd reported as 50,000 to 60,000 in the mainstream media, is this an indication of reduced support for Najib and his 1Malaysia slogan as compared to the public support given to his predecessor not only after Abdullah won the biggest-ever Barisan Nasional electoral mandate in the March 2004 general elections but also after he had suffered the worst Barisan Nasional electoral defeat in the political tsunami of March 8, 2008 general elections?
For both occasions in November 2004 and October 2008, the mainstream media reported 200,000-strong crowds for Abdullah’s Hari Raya Open House.
Or were these crowd figures during Abdullah’s premiership completely unreliable and unfair to Najib as they were very inflated figures multiplied three or four-fold?
As for Mahathir’s Hari Raya Open House as Prime Minister, Berita Harian reported in 2002 a crowd of 50,000. (BH 17.12.2001)
Be that as it may, the lesson to be drawn is that one should not succumb to the fallacy of automatically equating the Prime Minister’s Hari Raya Open House crowd with support for his 1Malaysia slogan, especially when Najib is very ambivalent as to its real meaning, sending out conflicting messages of what he himself understood as 1Malaysia.
This was illustrated by his Hari Raya Message where he called on Muslims and the people of Malaysia to strengthen harmony and break down any prejudice for the sake of the future generation.
While this call finds common support, his subsequent statement deploring ”certain quarters who peddle hatred and try to deny this” highlights how polarized and divided Malaysians have become – with Malaysians sharply divided as to who are these “certain quarters who peddle hatred and try to deny this” with the Shah Alam cow-head protest sacrilege as the latest example.
1Malaysia would have halted the brain-drain of the best and brightest of Malaysians overseas. But there are no such signs. Confidence in Najib’s 1Malaysia cannot be high when a commentator ended his article yesterday about the dilemma of the Malay middle class with the question: “Is it any wonder that some Malays – some of the best and brightest – are starting to vote with their feet?” (Karim Raslan – “Caught between two extremes” Star 22.9.09)
If the nation is moving towards 1Malaysia, we should become increasingly competitive internationally, but three recent indicators show the reverse is the case for Malaysia – that we are losing in the international competitiveness race, viz:
- Three-place fall from 21st to 24th ranking in World Economic Forum (WEF) Global Competitiveness Report 2009-2010;
- Two-place fall in the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business Rankings 2009 from 21st to 23rd placing.
- A net FDI outflow of US6 billion in 2008, more than double the US$2.7 billion net outflow posted in the previous year – Unctad’s World Investment Report 2009 released last week.
Time is running out for Najib to salvage the 1Malaysia slogan before it is dismissed as an empty and meaningless motto like previous slogans of his predecessors.
We are used to figures thrown about to justify a given situation to suit BN. There is no necessity on their part to justify those figures for our benefit.
My cynical mind tells me that while a larger figure gives a good impression of strong support, it also helps the caterer to claim more than actually served. It would help both parties to inflate if there were collusion for mutual benefit. If the caterer had been honest, then a rough estimation would show whether it made any sense to an exceptionally large estimate of turnout.
Many who turned up at such an event are people who are curious, eg. first timers and tourists, and those who want a free meal and chance to mingle with the PM and other VVIPs, so it would be silly to equate such numbers to popular support for 1Malaysia. If, like in some cases where transport and allowance were provided as well, then it would be a ‘sponsored’ support!
if najib equates open hse attendance as support 4 him, then he must b desperate 4 acceptance.
n if he has 2 stoop 2 inflating figures, then he really doesnt have support !!!!
Aiya, saya pun pergi makan, tapi saya sokong DAP! Malaysian Malaysia, bukan 1Malaysia!